For the best chicken pot pie makers, I’d start with the Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker as the best overall option for shoppers who want a dedicated pie appliance, while the FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker stands out for its included crust cutter and the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker for small individual portions. The main tradeoff is between a purpose-built format and flexibility: compact makers suit single-serve pies, but they limit pie size and batch capacity. Also compare how each design handles filled pastry and how much hands-on shaping it requires. I’ve ranked these six around practical fit for chicken pot pies, ease of use, and useful design differences. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching a maker to your kitchen.
Get kitchen gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker ranks first because its dedicated pie-making focus makes it the clearest all-around choice for this specific use, rather than a general mini-pie format.
- FineMade’s included crust cutter is a meaningful convenience for cooks who want help forming pastry rounds, though that feature matters less if you already own cutters or prefer hand-shaped crusts.
- Mini makers favor individual portions over family-size pies. Buyers cooking for several people should check cavity count and pie dimensions before choosing a compact model.
- Several products share the mini pie-and-quiche format, so differences in included tools and intended workflow may matter more than the broad category name.
- Chicken filling needs room and careful portioning. Overfilling a small pastry cavity can make sealing and cleanup harder, so capacity and filling consistency should guide the choice.
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker |  | Best for Batch-Made Bite-Size Pies | Capacity: 6 mini pies or quiches | Mini pie diameter: 2.75 inches | Product dimensions: 2 x 10 x 4 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker |  | Best for Quick, Versatile Cooking | Model: 4805 | Wattage: 1000 watts | Settings: 1 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter |  | Best for Larger Handheld Portions | Capacity: Up to 3 pocket pies | Pocket pie size: 4.5 x 2.5 inches | Wattage: 750 watts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Quiche Maker |  | Best for Simple Four-Piece Batches | Capacity: Up to 4 bite-size pies or quiches | Wattage: 800 watts | Voltage: 110 volts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie Maker, Red |  | Best for Guided Four-Pie Batches | Model: FPSBPMM980 | Capacity: 4 pies | Coating: Nonstick | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker |  | Best for Batch-Making Mini Pies | Brand: CucinaPro | Capacity: Up to 6 mini pies, quiches, or tarts | Wattage: 980 W | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| chicken pot pie maker | Capacity | Coating | Wattage | Dimensions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche | 6 mini pies or quiches | Non-stick | — | — |
| Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker | — | Nonstick | 1000 watts | 9.61 x 10.59 x 5.12 inches |
| FineMade Mini Electric Pocket | Up to 3 pocket pies | Nonstick | 750 watts | 9.5 x 9.5 x 3.8 inches |
| Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Q | Up to 4 bite-size pies or quiches | Nonstick | 800 watts | — |
| Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie | 4 pies | Nonstick | 1400 watts | — |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche | Up to 6 mini pies, quiches, or tarts | — | 980 W | 10.5 × 4 × 10 inches |
More Details on Our Top Picks
MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker
The MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker stands out when you want six small portions in one batch rather than a few larger hand pies. Its 2.75-inch wells suit tasting portions, party bites, or a spread of different fillings, while the included dough-cutting circle helps keep pastry sizing consistent. Compared with the FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker, it makes more pieces at once, but the FineMade produces larger pocket pies that are easier to serve as individual snacks. The non-stick coating supports release and cleanup, and the recipe manual gives new owners a starting point. The main compromise is portion size: these are too small for anyone expecting a substantial, single-serving chicken pot pie.
Pros:- Makes six mini pies or quiches in one batch
- Dough-cutting circle helps create evenly sized pastry rounds
- Non-stick coating supports easier food release and cleanup
- Includes an instruction manual with recipes
Cons:- Small 2.75-inch pies are better suited to snacks than full meals
- Its batch size and format do not produce larger pocket pies like the FineMade
Best for: Hosts and families who want to serve several bite-size pot pies or quiches at once.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking full individual meal portions, since each pie is only 2.75 inches in diameter.
- Capacity:6 mini pies or quiches
- Mini pie diameter:2.75 inches
- Product dimensions:2 x 10 x 4 inches
- Item weight:4.29 pounds
- Coating:Non-stick
- Included accessories:Dough-cutting circle and instruction manual with recipes
- Model number:MTF-MPB-740
Our verdict“Choose the MasterChef if serving six bite-size pies per batch matters more than making meal-sized portions.”
Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker
The Sunbeam Pie Magic is the flexible pick for cooks who want one appliance for pot pies, quiche, fruit pies, and even pizza. Its stated cooking time of 10 minutes or less makes it a stronger fit for quick portions than the MasterChef, which focuses on six smaller pies and includes a dough guide rather than emphasizing speed. Two dough cutters help prep pastry, and the cord-wrap design makes this model easier to put away between uses. The tradeoff is control: it has one setting, so there is no option to tailor the heat for different crusts or fillings. Buyers who want several pieces at once may also prefer the four-pie Sunbeam FPSBPMM980, while this model suits cooks prioritizing variety and compact storage.
Pros:- Handles pot pies, quiches, fruit pies, and pizza
- Cooks pies in 10 minutes or less, according to the product description
- Includes two dough cutters
- Compact body and wrapping cord simplify storage
Cons:- Only one cooking setting limits control over different recipes
- The product data does not specify a pie capacity
- Polycarbonate construction may not suit buyers seeking a metal-bodied appliance
Best for: Cooks in small kitchens who want a compact appliance for quick savory and sweet pies.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want adjustable cooking settings or need a clearly stated multi-pie capacity for family meal prep.
- Model:4805
- Wattage:1000 watts
- Settings:1
- Dimensions:9.61 x 10.59 x 5.12 inches
- Weight:4 pounds
- Material:Polycarbonate
- Coating:Nonstick
- Included components:Two dough cutters
- Special feature:PTFE-free
Our verdict“Pick the Sunbeam Pie Magic for quick recipe variety and compact storage, not for adjustable heat or a specified high-capacity batch.”
FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker with Crust Cutter
For chicken pot pies that need to work as handheld snacks or compact lunches, the FineMade Pocket Pie Maker offers a more useful shape than the MasterChef’s tiny round pies. It makes up to three 4.5 x 2.5-inch pocket pies per batch, trading the MasterChef’s six-piece output for larger individual portions. The included crust cutter helps standardize the pastry, and the nonstick surface is intended to simplify cleanup. At 750 watts, this model has less listed power than the 1400-watt Sunbeam FPSBPMM980, which makes four pies, though wattage alone does not establish cooking speed. Its capacity is still limited to three, so it is better for a small household or snack prep than feeding a crowd in one round.
Pros:- Makes pocket pies measuring 4.5 x 2.5 inches
- Crust cutter helps prepare evenly sized pastry
- Nonstick surface is designed for easier cleaning
- Compact dimensions make storage more manageable
Cons:- Makes only up to three pies per batch
- Lower listed wattage than the four-pie Sunbeam FPSBPMM980
- No adjustable settings are specified
Best for: Small households and lunch-preppers who prefer larger handheld pot pies over bite-size portions.
Not ideal for: Hosts or larger families who need more than three pies per batch, or buyers seeking multiple cooking settings.
- Capacity:Up to 3 pocket pies
- Pocket pie size:4.5 x 2.5 inches
- Wattage:750 watts
- Voltage:120 volts
- Dimensions:9.5 x 9.5 x 3.8 inches
- Material:Stainless steel
- Coating:Nonstick
- Special features:BPA-free, PFOA-free, PTFE-free
- Included accessory:Crust cutter
Our verdict“Choose the FineMade for larger handheld portions and a compact footprint, provided three pies per batch are enough.”
Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Quiche Maker
The Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Quiche Maker is a straightforward option for making four bite-size portions without a complicated control setup. Its 800-watt design and single setting keep operation simple, while the nonstick plates are intended to make cleanup less involved. Compared with the Sunbeam Pie Magic, the Aoruru specifies a four-piece capacity, giving buyers a clearer idea of how much one batch yields; the Sunbeam instead emphasizes broader recipe variety and a quick stated cook time. Aoruru’s compact format suits limited storage, but its plastic materials and single setting make it a less adaptable choice than models with more cooking information or accessories. The bite-size format also means these pies are better for snacks or sides than substantial individual meals.
Pros:- Makes up to four pies or quiches at once
- Simple single-setting operation
- Nonstick plates are intended to ease cleanup
- Compact design is convenient to store
Cons:- Only one setting offers limited cooking control
- Plastic materials may feel less substantial than the FineMade’s stainless steel
- Bite-size capacity is not suited to full individual pot pie meals
Best for: Beginners and small households who want a simple appliance for four bite-size pies or quiches.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want larger meal-sized pies, adjustable settings, or a more substantial construction material.
- Capacity:Up to 4 bite-size pies or quiches
- Wattage:800 watts
- Voltage:110 volts
- Settings:1
- Coating:Nonstick
- Materials:Plastic
- Material certifications:Lead-free, PFAS-free, PFOA-free
- Included components:Waffle plates
- Warranty:Limited warranty
Our verdict“Choose Aoruru for an uncomplicated four-piece batch of small pies, but skip it if you need larger portions or cooking control.”
Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie Maker, Red
The Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 makes sense for cooks who want four mini pies at once and prefer clear visual cues during baking. Its power and ready-to-bake indicator lights help show when the unit is on and ready, while the included pastry cutter and pie press support consistent shaping. Compared with the Aoruru, it adds those prep tools and indicator lights; the Aoruru is the more compactly described option, with a lighter 800-watt specification. Sunbeam lists 1400 watts, but the product data does not give a cooking-time claim, so that figure should not be taken as proof of a faster batch. At 7.2 pounds, it is heavier than the 4-pound Sunbeam Pie Magic, and its four-pie output still calls for multiple rounds when serving more people.
Pros:- Makes four mini pies at once
- Power and ready-to-bake lights provide clear operating cues
- Includes a pastry cutter and pie press
- Nonstick cooking plates support food release
Cons:- At 7.2 pounds, it is heavier than the Sunbeam Pie Magic
- Four-pie capacity may require repeat batches for larger groups
- Product data does not specify pie dimensions or a cooking-time claim
Best for: Home cooks who want four mini pot pies per batch plus tools and lights that guide pastry prep and baking.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a lightweight appliance for frequent storage or want to cook more than four pies in one batch.
- Model:FPSBPMM980
- Capacity:4 pies
- Coating:Nonstick
- Wattage:1400 watts
- Voltage:100 volts
- Weight:7.2 pounds
- Color:Red
- Material:Plastic
- Included accessories:Pastry cutter and pie press
Our verdict“Choose this Sunbeam for four-piece batches with helpful prep accessories and indicator lights, if its weight is not a storage concern.”
CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker
The CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche Maker suits cooks who want several individual servings ready in one round: it bakes up to six mini pies, quiches, or tarts and includes a cutter to size pastry consistently. That makes it more useful for a small gathering than a maker focused on just a few portions, while its compact 10.5 × 4 × 10-inch body is easier to store than a full-size countertop oven. The PFAS-free ceramic nonstick interior helps baked crusts release and makes cleanup less involved. The tradeoff is scale: these are mini pies, not a family-size chicken pot pie, so larger meals still call for a traditional oven. Compared with the Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker, the CucinaPro’s clearest draw is its six-item capacity; choose it for batch portions, not a single large pie.
Pros:- Bakes up to six mini pies, quiches, or tarts in one batch.
- Included dough cutter helps make pastry rounds consistent.
- PFAS-free ceramic nonstick interior supports easier release and cleanup.
- Compact dimensions and 4.2-pound weight make storage more manageable.
Cons:- Limited to mini-sized portions rather than a full-size chicken pot pie.
- Larger baked dishes still require a separate traditional oven.
Best for: Cooks preparing individual chicken pot pies or savory tarts for several people who want a compact appliance and consistent pastry sizing.
Not ideal for: Anyone who wants to bake one family-size chicken pot pie in the appliance or needs it to replace a traditional oven for larger dishes.
- Brand:CucinaPro
- Capacity:Up to 6 mini pies, quiches, or tarts
- Wattage:980 W
- Dimensions:10.5 × 4 × 10 inches
- Weight:4.2 pounds
- Interior:PFAS-free nonstick ceramic coating
- Included component:Dough cutting circle
Our verdict“Choose the CucinaPro if you want to batch-bake up to six individual savory pies; skip it if your goal is a full-size chicken pot pie.”
How We Picked
I ranked these makers by how well their stated format and included features suit homemade chicken pot pies, not by treating every electric pie appliance as interchangeable. I weighed portion size and batch practicality alongside the likely effort involved in shaping pastry, fitting filling, and serving finished pies. A dedicated pie maker such as the Sunbeam Pie Magic earned the lead because its purpose is clear; compact pie-and-quiche machines remain compelling for cooks who prioritize smaller servings or countertop footprint.
I also looked at the buyer tradeoffs implied by each product’s design: whether an included cutter can simplify pastry prep, whether a mini format fits the household’s serving needs, and whether a model appears better suited to beginners or cooks with an established pastry routine. The FineMade cutter gives it a distinct role, while the MasterChef, Aoruru, Sunbeam FPSBPMM980, and CucinaPro options are compared as compact alternatives rather than assumed to be identical. Since detailed performance and construction specifications are not provided here, I avoid claims about cooking speed, durability, or cleaning results that cannot be supported.
| chicken pot pie maker | Coating | Material |
|---|---|---|
| MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche | Non-stick | — |
| Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker | Nonstick | Polycarbonate |
| FineMade Mini Electric Pocket | Nonstick | Stainless steel |
| Aoruru Electric Mini Pie and Q | Nonstick | — |
| Sunbeam FPSBPMM980 4-Piece Pie | Nonstick | Plastic |
| CucinaPro Mini Pie and Quiche | — | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Chicken Pot Pie Makers
Choosing a pie maker for chicken filling takes more than matching the appliance name to the recipe. I’d start with serving size and pastry workflow, then check how the appliance fits your kitchen habits and the way you plan to cook.
Match Pie Size to How You Serve Dinner
A mini pie maker can be a good fit for packed lunches, individual dinners, or serving guests with different preferences. It may be a poor match if you want one large pie to share, since several small portions mean more assembly and potentially more batches. Check the cavity dimensions and the number of pies made per cycle rather than relying on words such as “mini” or “four-piece.” Think about whether your household prefers seconds; a compact appliance can turn a simple dinner into repeated rounds of cooking. For family meals, compare total servings per batch with the time you are willing to spend at the counter.
Plan for the Filling, Not Just the Crust
Chicken pot pie filling is heavier and wetter than many sweet pie fillings, so the amount and texture of the filling affect how easily a small pie seals. Thick, cooled filling is generally easier to portion than a hot, loose mixture, which can spill while the top crust is fitted. Avoid assuming a cavity can hold the same amount as a similarly sized open pastry shell. Leave room around the edge for sealing, even if that means making more pies. If you often cook with generous chunks of chicken and vegetables, favor a design whose portions can accommodate them without compressing the filling.
Decide How Much Pastry Shaping Help You Want
An included cutter, as on the FineMade, can standardize pastry pieces and reduce guesswork when you are new to individual pies. It does not remove every step: dough still needs to be rolled, placed, filled, and sealed carefully. Experienced bakers may prefer choosing their own cutter size or shaping pastry by hand, making an included tool less valuable. Before buying, check whether you already own a rolling pin, pastry cutter, or suitable round cutter. The best choice depends on whether you want the appliance to simplify preparation or simply cook pies you have already assembled.
Treat Capacity and Batch Time as a Pair
The number of pies made at once matters, but it only tells part of the story. A maker with several small cavities may suit a household that wants uniform individual servings, while a single larger format may better suit a shared meal. Consider how long you can spend preparing and cooking successive batches on a busy evening. If you cook for a crowd, a countertop oven or conventional oven may handle more pies at once than a compact electric maker. Compare the appliance’s output with your usual meal size, not just the headline cavity count.
Check Counter Space, Storage, and Cleanup
Small appliances still need a practical home between uses, so measure available storage and counter space before choosing a model. A compact footprint is helpful only if the cooking capacity fits your needs; a tiny unit that must run through many batches can be inconvenient. Look for clear manufacturer guidance on cleaning, especially around hinges, edges, and any fixed cooking plates where filling might escape. Do not assume a nonstick surface or removable part without confirming it in the product specifications. If you expect to make pies often, easy access for wiping down the appliance may matter as much as its cooking format.
Pay More for a Feature You Will Use
Extra accessories are useful when they solve a repeated problem, not just because they come in the box. A cutter may be worthwhile for a beginner who wants repeatable pastry rounds, while an experienced baker might get more value from a simple maker that fits existing tools. Likewise, a specialized pie appliance can make sense for frequent individual pies, but occasional cooks may prefer a standard oven and pie dish they already own. Compare the appliance’s role with your broader cooking routine before buying a dedicated device. The right spend is the one that reduces work you actually dislike without adding storage or cleanup burdens.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a mini pie maker handle a full chicken pot pie dinner for a family?
It can, but the number of servings per cycle may make the process slower than using a large pie dish in a conventional oven. Check both the cavity count and the finished pie dimensions, then compare the total output with your household’s usual portions. If you need several batches, prepare the filling and pastry ahead so assembly does not interrupt dinner. A mini maker is most practical when individual servings are useful, such as for lunches or varied portion sizes. For a single shared centerpiece, a conventional pie pan may be a better fit.
Does a chicken pot pie maker need a special recipe?
Not necessarily, but recipes may need adjustments for cavity size and the appliance’s cooking format. Use filling that is thick enough to stay inside the pastry, and avoid packing each pie to the rim. A conventional pot pie recipe may make more filling than a compact maker can use in one session. Start with a small test batch and follow the appliance maker’s instructions for pastry placement and cooking. This helps you learn the portion size before committing a full recipe.
Is an included crust cutter worth choosing a maker for?
It can be worthwhile if you do not already have a cutter that matches the pie cavities or if consistent pastry rounds would make preparation easier. The FineMade includes a crust cutter, giving it a practical advantage for buyers who want a more guided setup. A cutter does not replace rolling and sealing the dough, though, so it will not remove all pastry work. If you already bake pies regularly, your existing tools may do the job just as well. Treat the accessory as a convenience rather than the main measure of cooking quality.
Should I choose a pie-and-quiche maker if I only plan to make chicken pot pies?
A pie-and-quiche model can still suit you if its portion size and cooking format match the pies you want to make. The extra versatility only adds value if you expect to prepare quiches or other pastries; otherwise, focus on how well the appliance fits pot pie portions and your kitchen routine. The MasterChef, Aoruru, and CucinaPro names signal a shared mini pie-and-quiche category, but buyers should compare each model’s stated capacity and included parts. Do not assume similarly named appliances have identical layouts or accessories. Check the manufacturer’s specifications before choosing between them.
When is a dedicated electric pie maker a better choice than baking pot pies in the oven?
A dedicated maker is more appealing when you regularly want individual pies and prefer an appliance built around that format. It can be less suitable when you need a large batch, a shared family pie, or the flexibility to use standard bakeware. Think about how often you will use the appliance, where you will store it, and whether its serving size fits your meals. A conventional oven remains a flexible choice for occasional pot pies and larger quantities. The appliance makes the most sense when its specific format solves a recurring cooking need.
Conclusion
For most shoppers focused on chicken pot pies, I’d choose the Sunbeam Pie Magic Pie Maker as the best overall because it has the clearest dedicated-pie role in this lineup. The FineMade Mini Electric Pocket Pie Maker is my best pick for beginners who want an included crust cutter, while the MasterChef Mini Pie and Quiche Baker is a sensible direction for cooks prioritizing small individual portions. I can’t confidently name a best-value or best-premium winner without reliable price and build specifications; compare those details directly before deciding. For a specific need—uniform pocket pies with pastry prep support—FineMade is the standout, while buyers who want a compact pie-and-quiche format can compare Aoruru, Sunbeam FPSBPMM980, and CucinaPro by their stated capacity and accessories. Choose based on the size of the pies you’ll actually serve, not the broad promise of a dedicated appliance.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
